When taking into consideration the case of Julia North, it is evident that if her individualized identicalness is defined as the character, beliefs, attitudes, and convictions she held before her accident, then that individual would be identified as that same individual psychologically after the accident. In favor of the storage theory, if actual memory is the deciding factor of what trifles up somebodyal identity, and that individual holds the archetype memories, then personal identity is found within the person where the memories originated. Since Julia Norths brain survived the train accident and Mary Frances brain went to excess after having a stroke, the only viable person who holds some(prenominal) actual memories would be Julia therefore, she is the atomic number 53 who kept her personal identity intact and ergo the peerless who survived the body transplant.
Before the accident, Julia had one body and then inherited another after the operation. This would opine that Julia was in possession of two bodies. This proves that a person cant be solely identified with a human body. Memory is the main(prenominal) component of identity and bodily identity is not necessary. Since the living(a) body remembered Julias thoughts and actions, the subsister was clearly Julia.
If the survivor has the capacity to sample their own identity without having the need to examine their body, then they would be aware that they have kept their personal identity intact.
The reasons which make a person be of worth, be cherish by loved ones, and makes them the unique individuals that they are, are mostly psychological. This explains the importance of personal identity. This statement is contradictory of what Jack Beaudine thought arguing that the survivor of the operation was actually Mary. Since bodily identity and personal discover are separate from each other in this case, one could argue that one cant exist without the other. This raises the question of what it means to be the same person. To be mentally or physically the...If you necessity to get a full essay, order it on our website: Orderessay
If you want to get a full essay, wisit our page: write my essay .
No comments:
Post a Comment